Opinions Please

[Norman Marshall]

Hi Guys,
          Ive been fiddling around with photoshop to get ideas for my next skin project and this is what ive come up so far, Feel free to coment 

[Cary_B]

They all look great, but the one with the check mark, and the one that says eject really stand out to me.

[Barcrest]

Yeah the check mark one looks really nice. 

[Norman Marshall]

The check mark style is the style i am toying with right now but on some buttons the font isnt looking
to good, Im using photoshop cs5 so i have a shed loads of fonts to choose from LOL, I guess its a matter of time before i find the right font

[coffee]

Check mark one looks great.

[ecbrad]

I like the last one. Classy look and will skin nicely with the square border in my opinion.

Brad

[Hitbig]

Glenn :
About a glossy black button??

[Norman Marshall]

Glenn :
About a glossy black button??

Like this one hitbig?



Uploaded with ImageShack.us

[Barcrest]

Glenn :
About a glossy black button??

Like this one hitbig?



Uploaded with ImageShack.us

This is really nice but the font is to fancy, As I have suggested previously AIREL tends to be the best for clear text. Do you think you could make a set of those to replace the menu buttons with the font as arial?

[Norman Marshall]

I have to say that ariel does look very nice on this button but do you think i could get away with a shadow or leave it plain ariel?

[Barcrest]

Plain ariel, the one with the shadow looks less like a button. 

[Norman Marshall]

Plain ariel it is then, Ill be making a start in the next couple of days and now ive found a different way of making the buttons hopefully i wont have problems with transparentcy like i have in the past

[Barcrest]

Plain ariel it is then, Ill be making a start in the next couple of days and now ive found a different way of making the buttons hopefully i wont have problems with transparentcy like i have in the past

There are 3 ways to fix the transparency issue.

1 is to make the image a transparent GIF like coffe does, this works ok.
2 make the background colour of the image unique in that it is not used anywhere else on the image
3 is to use a transparent PNG and for me to change the code.

[coffee]

3 is to use a transparent PNG and for me to change the code.

I'll be able to make very very nice looking skins.

[Norman Marshall]

3 is to use a transparent PNG and for me to change the code.

I'll be able to make very very nice looking skins.

Coffee does this mean youll be wanting a copy of these buttons in PNG format? if so do you want them Alpha channel, Indexed or True colour?